Review: Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man: What Men Really Think about Love, Relationships, Intimacy, and Commitment

Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man: What Men Really Think about Love, Relationships, Intimacy, and Commitment

My rating: 1 of 5 stars

I'm actually going to review this book as I read it. I actually find it very simplistic in dealing with relationships. Steve here deems men to be simple creatures who are all basically the same regardless of upbringing, culture or creed. He makes some really sweeping assumptions about both men and women. The fact that he assumes that all men are running some sort of game on us women tells me that he really does not have a broad view of people. To me the book sounds like the advice that a father gives to his girl child before he allows her to go on dates with guys, just to make sure that she is not duped into sleeping with them.

I must say the book is an extremely easy read as I was able to finish it within 24hours. But honestly towards the end I was really tired of the advice that Steve is dishing out. I’m honestly surprised that this book has made it to the best seller list and I guess it’s a testament as to how desperate we are as women to try and have successful relationships with these men. It is really sad to think that so many women are desperately seeking solutions in dealing with their relationships to no avail.

Now back to my review of the book, really the best thing about it is the fact that it is such an easy read and that you really don’t spend that much time getting through it. Which in itself is a blessing as honestly the advice does become a bit tedious towards the end. Really the whole book is a bit of a big joke and looking at it from that perspective makes reading it bearable.

Obviously not everything he says in the books is trash but in the same breath he really does not delve much deeper into the subject. The classic mistake he makes is in assuming that all men are the same and all women are looking for the same things in relationships. Mind you there is an audience for this book, narrow as it may be. But following everything he says in this book to the letter will really reduce your relationship to a game instead of something in which two grown intelligent people are building.

In terms of the advice it all sounds like the advice that a father will give to his daughter before she goes out on her first date. And this is evident when Steve retells the incident between his father in law and one his daughter's dates. It’s all the warning that a father will give his daughter to make sure that the men out there don't take advantage of her and use her for sex. Some of this advice might apply to a teenager getting to grips with the opposite sex. But once you reach a certain level of wisdom and maturing really the game playing is out of the question.

The fact that he assumes that as women we have no idea what some men are after really belittles our intelligence. Of course we know and sometimes it is exactly the same thing that we are after, sex. I just find the book a little condescending towards wise and experienced women because in all honesty if I have to run a game on you, in order to get you, then maybe we should not even be doing this thing.

Comments

Rowena M said…
I was so disappointed by this book! I'm glad to see I'm not the only one.
Ziyanda Xaso said…
No you're not the only one Rowena, I'm even more disappointed by the fact that Oprah discussed it in her show. I would have been okay if it was all done as a gag but to promote that women should take the book seriously and to heart really took relationship professionals a couple of year back!
Rowena M said…
Agreed! And I don't mean to sound judgemental but I'm not taking relationship advice from a man on his third marriage who cheated on his ex wives with the next wife. I love your review by the way; it's spot on!
Amanda Gida said…
I loved this book! Gave me something to think about...
Ziyanda Xaso said…
Really Amanda Gida? What about it did you love?
Amanda Gida said…
I dunno... I think we all waiting for a prince charming to sweep us off our feet, yet we dont expressly say what we want, let men disrespect us... And then the dude around the way... Who is responsible has a job, maybe doesnt have the white horse, but certainly helps you with things... He's a dude you should think upon...
Ziyanda Xaso said…
But that's not what Steve says in his book though. He's is narrowly classifying all men and saying to women this is the formula that you need to follow to ensure that you have a successful relationship! I disagree with the advice he gives in the book because I do believe that when you in an adult and mature relationship you don't need to be playing games with each other. And him saying that the only thing that all men are after is sex and we as women must use sex and dangle it like a carrot, is just plain old school.
Amanda Gida said…
Ja but old school works! Maybe you dont need to wait 90days but you do need to get a little jist of what dude is about and you can make up your own mind...
Ziyanda Xaso said…
this is my point exactly Amanda Gida every situation is unique and different and we each need to make up our own minds about them and that's the only way we gain experience and wisdom, through trial and error. Sometimes we have to hit our heads against that brick wall a few times for us to be able to learn the lesson contained in the experience! Life is there to be lived and experienced is all I'm saying!

Popular posts from this blog

Understanding Ourselves - The Meaning and Importance of Initiation

The Camel, the Needle Head, and the Rich Man: What Christians Really Think About Wealth

Power to the People